NHL Trade Talk Midday Review: Reaves, Nurse, Marner, Campbell, Graves

In an NHL Trade Talk midday review, Jim Parsons shared a comprehensive review following a busy weekend in the NHL. The fallout from the Toronto Maple Leafs’ overtime win against the Edmonton Oilers has created significant waves, with Ryan Reaves’ suspension taking center stage. Here’s a breakdown of the critical points Parsons reviewed, with insights into what they mean moving forward.

---

---

Reaves Suspended for Five Games After Hit on Nurse

The NHL Department of Player Safety handed Ryan Reaves a five-game suspension for a controversial hit on Darnell Nurse. During the second period of Saturday’s game, the play resulted in Nurse leaving the ice and not returning. While Nurse appeared in good spirits post-game, his short-term availability remains in question.

The league justified the suspension by citing Reaves’ history of supplementary discipline and their determination that the hit was avoidable. This incident further fuels the debate over the NHL’s handling of dangerous hits and repeat offenders. For the Oilers, Nurse’s absence could have caused a significant blow to their blue line. Josh Brown is being called up to fill the gap.

Mitch Marner’s Heroics Overshadowed by Controversy

The Maple Leafs’ victory, secured in overtime by Mitch Marner’s impressive two-way play, has been somewhat overshadowed by the Reaves-Nurse incident. Marner stopped a high-danger chance from Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl and scored the game-winner.

Despite the win, Toronto faces its own challenge. How can Reaves’ physical presence be replaced in his absence? Reaves was brought in to add grit to the Maple Leafs, but the team now must manage without his enforcer role during critical games.

Jack Campbell’s Waiver News Adds to the Drama

In a separate yet related review, the Detroit Red Wings waived goaltender Jack Campbell following his exit from the NHL’s Player Assistance Program. Although not directly tied to the Maple Leafs-Oilers game, Campbell’s situation reminds us of the shifting nature of NHL rosters and player fortunes.

Pittsburgh Penguins: Ryan Graves Scratched and Trade Rumors Begin

Ryan Graves was a healthy scratch for the Pittsburgh Penguins. This review fuels speculation about potential moves under President of Hockey Operations Kyle Dubas. With Dubas reportedly “open for business,” teams around the league will watch for any developments.

The Bottom Line: What This Means for the Maple Leafs and Oilers

The aftermath of Reaves’ suspension will dominate discussions in Toronto, primarily as the team evaluates whether the tradeoff between his physicality and potential disciplinary risks is worthwhile. Meanwhile, Edmonton must navigate a critical stretch without one of their top defensemen, further exposing their lack of defensive depth.

As the NHL continues to crack down on dangerous hits, teams like the Maple Leafs and Oilers grapple with the fine line between aggressive play and player safety. Will this incident adjust how players approach physicality, or is it simply the latest chapter in hockey’s ongoing evolution?

For more updates, visit NHLTradeTalk.com and stay tuned for developments in this story.

Related: NHL Trade Talk Morning Review: Nurse, Reaves, Hall, Cap Drama