Can the Maple Leafs Win With Auston Matthews Leading?

When I wrote about the Toronto Maple Leafs’ depth this week, my argument was pretty simple: give Auston Matthews a real supporting cast and stop asking him to be a shutdown defensive stopper. He’s the best goal-scorer in the game. Let him score. Build a team around him that can handle the dirty work so he doesn’t have to.

A reader pushed back on that, and honestly, it stuck with me. I want to take a closer look at the critique and engage with it.

---

---

The Critique: Real Stars Lead By Example, and the Maple Leafs Don’t Have Them

Their point was that real stars don’t get to pick and choose. They lead by example, they do whatever the team needs, and that’s exactly what’s been missing in Toronto. Much of the same core group has been in that room year after year, and while the Maple Leafs have constantly rebuilt the roster around them, the results haven’t budged. This offseason was no different, they argued. Marner’s gone, the front office’s been shaken up, and yet the team’s leadership at the top has stayed the same. Don’t expect a different outcome.

That’s a fair shot to take. Toronto has really cycled through complementary players over the past decade while the leadership group has remained remarkably stable. If the definition of a franchise player includes showing up in all situations, not just the ones that flatter your stat line, then asking more of Matthews isn’t problematic.

My Pushback: There Are Two Different Maple Leafs Arguments Here

But I’d push back a little too. There’s a difference between “Matthews should defend better” and “the leadership group is why this team hasn’t broken through.” Those get treated like the same argument, and they’re not. One’s about deployment and coaching decisions. The other is a much murkier claim about culture and accountability that’s really hard to prove from the outside. It’s also worth remembering Matthews has been searching for a consistent linemate since Marner left. That looks a lot more like a fit problem than a heart problem.

So where does that leave us? Maybe both things are true at once. The Maple Leafs probably do need more from their leadership group in big moments. And they also probably need to stop building the roster like the top-six alone can carry a Cup run. It’s not really either-or.

I wonder what fans think. Is it a leadership problem, a roster problem, or both? Whatever the answer, we’ll start to learn soon enough. We are only a short time away from the start of the regular season.

Related: NHL Trade Talk Recap: Senators, Oilers & Hockey Night in Canada