Edmonton Oilers
Matthew Tkachuk’s Praise for the Oilers Sounded Like a Direct Shot at Stuart Skinner
Matthew Tkachuk praised the Edmonton Oilers’ new style, but his comments on Devon Levi may have been a subtle jab at Stuart Skinner.
The Edmonton Oilers are playing a brand of hockey that looks strikingly familiar. In many ways, it resembles the style the Florida Panthers have perfected over the past several seasons.
It’s the same blueprint Florida used to defeat Edmonton in back-to-back Stanley Cup Finals in 2024 and 2025: a suffocating, structured system built around puck management, relentless pressure, and minimizing mistakes. Dump-ins are often preferred over risky entries, and the safe play is usually the right play.
The Oilers leaned heavily into that approach Tuesday night, defeating the Panthers 5-2 in a game that showcased just how much this team has changed. Edmonton controlled large stretches of play, surrendered very little defensively, and after building a 4-0 lead, effectively shut Florida down.
Devon Levi was excellent in goal, but the biggest story wasn’t the goaltending. It was the way the Oilers played in front of him.
Oilers Taking a Page from Florida’s Playbook?
Over the summer, Mike Babcock spoke about one of the simplest coaching philosophies in hockey: steal what works.
The best organizations identify successful traits around the league and incorporate them into their own systems. Based on what we’re seeing this season, the Oilers appear to have borrowed a few pages from Florida’s playbook.
Both Paul Maurice and Matthew Tkachuk commented on Edmonton’s evolving style before and after Wednesday’s game. The Oilers are no longer playing the wide-open, run-and-gun hockey that defined much of the McDavid era. They’re more aggressive in their own zone, more committed defensively, and far more willing to dump pucks deep rather than force low-percentage plays through the neutral zone.
The result has been fewer rush chances against and a more predictable environment for Edmonton’s goaltenders. When asked what’s different about the Oilers this season, Tkachuk said:
“Ya, maybe they were a little bit less run and gun and I noticed that they pressure a little bit more in their zone. Which, is kind of how we play a little bit.”
It’s a notable observation from someone who has seen Edmonton as often as Tkachuk has over the years.
Maurice made a similar point before the game, noting how dramatically different the Oilers look compared to previous seasons.
Did Tkachuk Take a Shot at Stuart Skinner?
The more interesting part of Tkachuk’s media availability came when discussing Edmonton’s goaltending. While praising the Oilers’ performance and the differences in the group from years past, Tkachuk voluntarily brought up Levi’s play.
“Big difference, I thought their goalie played really, really well today and made some incredible saves. He’s a really good goalie.”
On the surface, it’s a compliment toward Levi. And based on how he played, it’s a deserved one. However, given the context of Edmonton and Florida’s recent history, it’s hard not to notice the wording.
Tkachuk was specifically discussing what makes this version of the Oilers different from previous editions. One of the first things he highlighted was the goaltending.
Whether intentional or not, some fans will interpret that as a subtle (or not so subtle when Tkachuk is involved) jab at Stuart Skinner, who spent years facing Florida’s stars in some of the biggest games of his career and is now with the Winnipeg Jets.
Tkachuk has never been shy about sharing his opinions on the Oilers. Over the years, he has frequently taken shots at various aspects of Edmonton’s roster beyond Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. Because of that history, his praise of Levi is likely to raise a few eyebrows among Oilers fans.
Was it a direct shot at Skinner? Only Tkachuk knows for sure. But the timing and context make it an interesting comment.

What It All Means
More than anything, Wednesday served as another example of how much the Oilers have evolved under Babcock.
This isn’t the freewheeling Edmonton team that tried to outscore its mistakes. The focus now is on structure, puck management, and making the smart play instead of forcing offense.
The system is creating clearer defensive assignments, limiting high-danger rush opportunities, and making life significantly easier on the goaltenders behind it. The analytics crowd may not love every aspect of the approach, but the results are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
If the Oilers continue to buy into this style, they may finally have found the formula needed to get over the hump and capture the Stanley Cup.
Next: The NHL’s 3 Biggest Success Stories at the Quarter Mark: What Went So Right?
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
