Edmonton Oilers
Host Says He’d Consider Trading Oilers’ Fan Favorite for Edvinsson
The Edmonton Oilers continue to be linked to Detroit Red Wings defenceman Simon Edvinsson, but acquiring the 23-year-old could come at a significant cost. During a recent Sports 1440 discussion, Oilers analyst Jason Gregor suggested he would be willing to overpay for Edvinsson, even mentioning Vasily Podkolzin as a player he would consider moving.
It’s an intriguing proposal that raises an important question: Would acquiring a potential franchise defenceman be worth sacrificing one of Edmonton’s most valuable forwards?
Edvinsson Could Transform the Oilers’ Defence
At 6-foot-6, Edvinsson possesses the size, mobility and defensive awareness that make him an attractive long-term option. With Mattias Ekholm approaching the latter stages of his career, Edmonton will eventually need someone capable of replacing his minutes alongside Evan Bouchard. Edvinsson could be that player.

In many ways, he represents what Edmonton hoped Philip Broberg would become, but with a higher defensive ceiling and a more established NHL resume. An eventual pairing of Edvinsson and Bouchard could anchor Edmonton’s blue line for years, while Ekholm, Connor Murphy and Ryan Shea would provide considerable defensive depth.
However, Edvinsson’s situation remains complicated. The unsigned restricted free agent faces a December 1 deadline to sign an NHL contract to remain eligible to play this season. Boston, San Jose and Toronto have also been linked to the young defenceman.
Trading Podkolzin Creates Another Problem
While Edvinsson’s upside is undeniable, moving Podkolzin would create a significant hole in Edmonton’s forward group. The 25-year-old has developed into an important contributor alongside Leon Draisaitl, providing physicality, relentless forechecking and an increasingly effective offensive game.
Their chemistry has become particularly valuable when Edmonton separates Draisaitl and Connor McDavid to create two dangerous scoring lines. Podkolzin’s impact extends beyond production. His work ethic, willingness to battle for possession and ability to retrieve pucks complement Draisaitl’s offensive strengths.
Draisaitl has publicly praised Podkolzin’s development and expressed how much he enjoys playing alongside him. That appreciation reflects the winger’s value both on the ice and within the dressing room. Perhaps most importantly, Podkolzin carries an extremely team-friendly $2.95-million cap hit through the 2028-29 season. Finding another player capable of providing similar production, physicality and chemistry at that price would be difficult.
Should the Oilers Make the Trade?
From a pure talent perspective, acquiring Edvinsson would be an outstanding move. Young, top-pairing-calibre defencemen rarely become available, and Edmonton cannot afford to ignore an opportunity to secure Ekholm’s eventual successor. However, the Oilers must consider their immediate championship aspirations.
Trading Podkolzin would strengthen an already talented defensive group while potentially weakening the forward depth needed for another lengthy playoff run. There’s also the question of what else Detroit would demand. Podkolzin alone might not be enough, particularly with multiple teams reportedly interested.
The Oilers should aggressively pursue Edvinsson, but Podkolzin shouldn’t be their preferred trade chip. A package involving Jake Walman, prospects and draft capital would be preferable, although Detroit would need sufficient incentive to accept Walman’s contract. Also Walman has trade protection, would he agree to a trade to go back to Detroit?
Edvinsson could become a cornerstone of Edmonton’s defence for the next decade. But sacrificing Draisaitl’s most reliable winger to acquire him could simply solve one problem while creating another. For a team trying to win the Stanley Cup now, that distinction matters.
Next: Crosby Responds As GM Confirms Penguins’ Potential Plans to Trade Veterans
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
