Connect with us

Anaheim Ducks

Cutter Gauthier’s Record Month Has Flyers Hurting After Huge Mistake

Cutter Gauthier has 17 goals in 9 games and four hat tricks in November. How the Flyers lost him and why fans are asking what went wrong.


Anaheim Ducks forward Cutter Gauthier became the first player in NHL history to score four hat tricks in a single month, and the month is only 17 days old. The pace is hard to believe, and it must be difficult for the Philadelphia Flyers to see, given the reason they were forced to trade him in the first place.

In nine November games, Gauthier has 17 goals and 20 points. He is riding a 10-game goal-scoring streak and, with 21 goals on the season, is tied with Edmonton’s Leon Draisaitl for the NHL lead. Only six teams in the last 30 years have recorded four hat tricks in one month. Gauthier’s 17 November goals are more than eight NHL teams have scored this month.

To say he’s taking the NHL by storm would be an understatement.

How the Flyers Lost Gauthier

What Gauthier is doing has put Philadelphia in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons. The Flyers drafted Gauthier and later traded him when he refused to play for the team. At the time, it was believed Gauthier was an entitled prospect with an attitude. It turns out, the Flyers were largely responsible for him turning sour.

According to NHL insider Elliotte Friedman, Gauthier wanted to leave college and turn pro. Then-general manager Chuck Fletcher had indicated the team would bring him in after his college season so he could start his contract. During that time, Fletcher was removed, and Daniel Briere was in as GM. He and the rest of the new management felt the environment was not right for a young player after a rough season.

“And the one thing I heard about Philly at the time is they tried to say that was a really awful year in Philly. And they tried to say to him, “You know, this is not a good environment for you, that, you know, we have a really bad situation right now and we don’t want to bring you into this.” And what they offered to do was they offered to have them play in the American Hockey League on an AHL tryout. Sometimes teams do that. And, Gauthier felt that he and his camp felt that there was a promise made and promise broken. And that’s, that’s kind of where it all started. And that’s eventually why he ended up being traded.”

Cutter Gauthier Ducks extension
Cutter Gauthier Ducks extension

Regret in Philadelphia

The Flyers have to be looking at what Gauthier is doing and kicking themselves. A clip from a Flyers broadcast in January 2024, one in which analysts, including Scott Hartnell, defended the organization and suggested moving Gauthier was wise, has been recirculated and mocked. Fans have criticized Briere, team president Keith Jones, and others, and some have joked that someone in the front office should be held accountable each time Gauthier scores a hat trick.

Others point to what Philadelphia received in return, defenseman Jamie Drysdale, and realize now that the trade itself was drastically uneven.

For Anaheim, this is nothing but great news. They just signed Gauthier to a big extension. At $13.5 million per season, he’s going to be seen as a bargain by the end of the year. It’s unlikely he keeps up this pace, but anything close will make him one of the top goal scorers in 2026-27. What the Flyers wouldn’t do to have a guy like that on their team right now.

Next: NHL Trade Talk Recap: Red Wings, Sabres & Oilers’ Big Surprise


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk