Toronto Maple Leafs
Should the Maple Leafs Trade William Nylander? Time Is Running Out
William Nylander responds to questions about his effort as the Maple Leafs’ losing streak continues. Is a trade a possibility?
Toronto Maple Leafs winger William Nylander is pushing back against mounting criticism of his effort as the team’s losing streak reached seven games. Some critics have begun asking whether the Leafs should consider moving him. “He’s playing probably the worst hockey I’ve ever seen him play,” said TSN OverDrive’s Bryan Hayes.
Nylander, who has long had strong support from Toronto’s fan base, is now facing serious questions about his compete level. “He looks like he doesn’t give a sh–,” said Matthew Barnaby. Critics say he might think he’s working hard, but if he were to watch the video back of his effort level in recent games, Nylander would probably be astonished by how much he looks disengaged on the ice.
He doesn’t seem to understand that the Leafs are at a point where they have to win seven of ten games, and six times this season to even make the playoffs. The conversation has moved from his production to whether a team can win with a player who appears to lack urgency.

Nylander has basically told everyone to chill out. He believes he’s doing what he can and just needs to play his game. “If you’re working hard, all the other stuff will come. I’m not worried about it,” he said. “I don’t really need to change anything. I just need to play my game.”
Analysts and fans are starting to wonder what he’s smoking.
He also doesn’t seem to grasp how dire the season has already become. “If we’re sitting there and it’s a playoff push in February or March, and you’re going on a six-game losing streak, then maybe you want to change something,” Nylander said. He added that the team has been playing better hockey recently and promised, “We are going to work our way out of this.” Only, the loss to Chicago on Tuesday says they aren’t playing well and he’s not doing anything to help.
Is It Time to Consider Trading Nylander?
Jay Rosehill believes the Leafs should consider trading Nylander while he is still in his prime, citing concerns about his effort and the chance to add a younger defenceman. Given he holds trade protection, that would be easier said than done. But, if the Maple Leafs could pull it off, it solves several of their salary cap problems. It gives them space for this season and relieves much of their tagging concerns for next season.
Questions recently raised the possibility that Nylander or Auston Matthews could eventually consider a move if things continue to go downhill. That would have sounded far-fetched a few months ago, but frustration is growing as the team struggles.
For now, Nylander says there is nothing to fix. It’s now up to the Maple Leafs to make him see that he’s very wrong.
Next: Where’s Erik Källgren When the Maple Leafs Need Him?
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
