Columbus Blue Jackets
Matthew Knies Has Been Up and Down in Columbus: Now What?
Matthew Knies started strong in Columbus, but can he become the elite forward the Blue Jackets hoped they were getting in the trade?
For so long, Toronto Maple Leafs’ Matthew Knies has been in trade rumours. But very few Maple Leafs fans ever believed he would be traded. He was too young, too good, and the team had developed him. He had a solid place on the Maple Leafs’ first line, alongside Auston Matthews. Interestingly, both players are from Arizona.
What a surprise when the Columbus Blue Jackets and the Maple Leafs traded two key players. The Maple Leafs got Kirill Marchenko, and the Blue Jackets picked up Knies. Knies was exactly the kind of player Columbus wanted. Marchenko was rumoured not to want to be there, but Knies was exactly the kind of player they wanted.
He was young, of solid character, and someone they felt would be part of the team for a long time. It also made sense because he was an American player playing in Canada, so the Midwest wasn’t such a bad fit for him.
Knies was also a solid producer. He had scored 23 goals and put up 66 points in this last season with the Maple Leafs. That kind of production, for a young player, could turn into something more. All he needed was a chance to be more involved. And even though he played on the first line in Toronto, he was still a secondary piece behind the Maple Leafs’ elite players.
In his first game with the Blue Jackets, he scored two goals and added an assist as the team beat the Buffalo Sabres 6-3. That was a historic moment for the Blue Jackets because he became the first Blue Jacket to score twice in his debut. Since then, however, things haven’t been quite so easy for Knies.
Knies Adjustment Has Taken Some Time
After his really strong start, Knies had a tough stretch through October and the first part of November. He had chances, but his offensive production simply wasn’t as good as the Blue Jackets had hoped.
When he first arrived, it looked like he found his offence immediately. However, reality soon hit. Knies was no longer playing in Toronto alongside teammates he had developed chemistry with over three seasons, particularly Auston Matthews. He was now being asked to develop chemistry with Adam Fantilli and to become a leader and one of the Blue Jackets’ top-six forwards.
That might have been too big of an adjustment for him, even if he had the talent. He needed some time to settle in. However, Knies has shown encouraging signs recently. He had points in four of his five games. He scored in two straight games and then added three points Thursday night against the Blackhawks with a power-play goal and two assists.

Columbus Needs More Than Just Goals From Knies
The Blue Jackets are starting to see that Knies might bring more to the lineup than just offence. He could become a physical power forward who isn’t afraid to get involved, stick up for his teammates, and dig in along the boards to win puck battles. His defence is improving, and that helps beyond whatever he produces on the scoreboard.
Knies has already shown that he is a competitor at the NHL level. The question now for the Blue Jackets is whether he can become a regular and solid offensive contributor.
The Blue Jackets did not trade for him because they wanted a useful forward. They wanted an elite forward, and they believe he could be that. They gave up one of their key players, Marchenko, to get him. The question now is whether Knies will develop into a team leader who can lead both on and off the ice.
It took him a while, but his recent November production is encouraging for the Blue Jackets. It may take some time before he becomes the player who collected 66 points in Toronto, but could he become a point-a-game player with the Blue Jackets? Perhaps he could. At least that’s what the Blue Jackets hope.
Related: Maple Leafs Blow Another 3-0 Lead: Is This Who They Are Now?
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
