Darryl Sittler’s Lasting Maple Leafs Legacy Is the Horrible Trade

If you’re a Toronto Maple Leafs fan and you don’t mind going back to the stuff that probably still stings, let’s revisit January 1982. That’s when Toronto traded Darryl Sittler—one of the best players in franchise history—and got a return that still makes people shake their heads.

Sittler wasn’t just “good.” He was the captain and the team’s heart and soul. At the time, he was the Maple Leafs’ all-time leading scorer, with 916 points, a record that stood until Mats Sundin surpassed him with 987.

---

---

Sittler Put Up One of the Best Games in NHL History in a Maple Leafs Uniform

And then there’s that moment everyone remembers: in 1976, Sittler put up 10 points against the Boston Bruins. Five decades later, he still holds the NHL record. In the 1970s, he was the face of the franchise. Fans loved him, teammates respected him, and every night he played hard at both ends of the ice.

So yeah… why would Toronto trade a player like that?

The short version is that the team fell apart behind the scenes. By the early ’80s, things were messy in the front office, with nonstop fights between management and the players. Sittler’s relationship with GM Punch Imlach and owner Harold Ballard deteriorated over contract issues, leadership disputes, and disagreements over where the team was headed. Eventually, it got to the point where a trade wasn’t really avoidable.

Sittler Went to the Philadelphia Flyers, with Costello, Ihnacak and a Draft Pick

The Maple Leafs moved him to the Philadelphia Flyers for Rich Costello, Peter Ihnacak, and a second-round draft pick. They later chose Ken Strong with that pick. Even then, the trade just didn’t make sense. Costello played 12 games for Toronto. The draft pick Toronto received eventually became Ken Strong, who played only 15 games with the Maple Leafs. Ihnacak had a single good season, putting up 28 goals and 66 points as a rookie. However, he never became the kind of impact piece Toronto needed. After that first spark, his production faded.

Meanwhile, Sittler kept scoring for the Flyers and later finished his career with the Red Wings in Detroit. He was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1989.

For the Maple Leafs, It Was the Worst Trade in the Franchise’s History

For the Maple Leafs, though, this trade became way more than a hockey deal. It turned into this ugly symbol of the Harold Ballard years. It was a time of personal conflicts, bad decisions, and an organization that kept missing what actually mattered. The Maple Leafs were Ballard’s toy, and he didn’t treat it well. Years after, there’s still a sense of the Curse of Harold Ballard. Many long-time Toronto fans still think it haunts the team.

Even today, it’s one of those trades that makes Maple Leafs fans wince. Trading a franchise icon is brutal in itself. Doing it for a return that barely gave anything back? That’s why it’s still one of the most painful chapters in Maple Leafs history. And perhaps the worst part, according to many who followed the team at the time, was the belief that the trade was driven more by personal conflict than hockey reasons.

Related: For Maple Leafs Fans, Jack Campbell’s Legacy Is Secure