Connect with us

Boston Bruins

People Livid About Maple Leafs Draft Pick Leverage Trade Option

Should the Toronto Maple Leafs get to benefit off of bad trades by leveraging two teams against each other? Many fans are upset.


The Toronto Maple Leafs’ first-round draft picks have become a real talking point, according to NHL insider Elliotte Friedman. During his Saturday Headlines report, Friedman noted that there are several parties wanting clarification on how the conditional picks will work depending on where the Maple Leafs finish this season.

Here’s the situation with Toronto’s first-round picks, for anyone unfamiliar with the conditions.

A couple of years ago, the Maple Leafs made two trades: one with Philadelphia for Scott Laughton and one with Boston for Brandon Carlo. In both deals, they sent out first-round picks over the next two years.

The conditions work like this:

  • If this upcoming June’s pick is not in the top 10, Philadelphia gets it, and Boston receives an unprotected 2028 first-round pick.
  • If the pick is in the top 10, Toronto chooses which team gets it. The other team gets an unprotected 2028 first-round pick.

Friedman said he tried to get clarity from the league on whether this is really how it works, and the answer is yes. It’s quite clear that Toronto holds the option on which team gets the pick.

Can the Maple Leafs Leverage Their Choice in a Trade for Additional Assets?

The second question is whether Toronto can use that option as leverage, for example, by going to the Flyers and negotiating. The answer is that it’s possible, but it would have to be part of a bigger deal. Friedman noted it has to be a bona fide trade that is unique from just a trade for “preferential choice.”

For example, the Leafs could make a trade with the Flyers for a smaller piece, then write as a condition on the trade that they would choose Philadelphia at the 2028 draft. It’s clear that the trade would be lopsided in favor of Toronto, only because the Flyers would know they were getting a first.

John Chayka Leafs trade
John Chayka Leafs trade

The catch here is that the Flyers or the Bruins wouldn’t want to make the trade until after the draft lottery to know for certain that Toronto’s pick is in the top 10.

People Are Livid the Maple Leafs Can Take Advantage Of This Situation

Friedman thinks it would be “awesome” if this happened. Others don’t necessarily agree. One fan wrote, “This is one of the most ridiculous things I’ve ever heard when it comes to a trade in professional sports. How is Toronto permitted to do this?” Another added, “Probably where I’d draw the line if I were the league (but I am not). One thing to pick who gets it. Got no problem with that. Another to have a bidding war on picks you already traded.”

The fact the season is falling apart for the Maple Leafs, based in large part on gambles they took that didn’t pan out, does not mean they should be rewarded. Getting to play two teams off of each other as they plummet to the bottom of the standings has not sat well with fans of the Bruins or the Flyers.

One fan wrote, “If I am the Flyers, here is what I give Toronto for the right to this year’s 1st-round pick. I give them nothing. The 2028 draft looks better than the 2027 draft so you’re set either way. Toronto should not benefit from the picks they traded. F— em.”

Next: What’s the Maple Leafs’ Biggest Problem? Can It Be Solved?


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk