Connect with us

Edmonton Oilers

The Oilers Are Winning, But One Dangerous Problem Should Force McDavid and Draisaitl Apart

The Oilers are among the NHL’s best teams early on, but a troubling trend is impossible to ignore and could force a major lineup change.


The Edmonton Oilers are off to their best start in years, sitting at 8-2-1 through 11 games. They are tied for fourth overall in the NHL and sit atop the Pacific Division alongside the Vegas Golden Knights, while still holding two games in hand.

On the surface, everything looks great. Edmonton has picked up wins against quality opponents, including the Utah Mammoth, Minnesota Wild, and defending Stanley Cup champion Carolina Hurricanes.

But beneath the strong record are some troubling warning signs, and the underlying numbers suggest the Oilers may be playing with fire if they continue down their current path.

Time to Split Up the Top Line?

The Oilers have dealt with their share of injury issues this season.

Zach Hyman, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, and Jason Dickinson have all missed time, significantly impacting Edmonton’s center depth. Hyman and Nugent-Hopkins have since returned, but Dickinson remains sidelined. The Oilers have also been without Matt Savoie all season after he looked like a legitimate top-line option alongside Connor McDavid late last year.

On the blue line, Edmonton has largely avoided major injuries until recently. Losing Mattias Ekholm is a significant blow. Arguably the club’s most complete defenseman, Ekholm plays a critical role beside Evan Bouchard on one of the NHL’s best pairings.

The injuries haven’t stopped head coach Mike Babcock from loading up his top line with McDavid and Leon Draisaitl together. Through 11 games, the strategy has worked from a results standpoint. The duo has been dominant, and Vasily Podkolzin’s breakout campaign has only strengthened that line further.

But Saturday’s embarrassing loss to the Toronto Maple Leafs highlighted an issue that has been lurking beneath the surface for weeks.

With Edmonton already lacking center depth, stacking the two best centers in hockey on the same line creates major problems lower in the lineup. Nugent-Hopkins no longer looks like a true second-line center and is likely better suited in a middle-six role or on the wing.

The top line continues to produce at an elite level. The problem is what happens when they’re not on the ice.

Edmonton Oilers 2024 season review
McDavid Draisaitl Oilers

Edmonton’s Bottom Six Is Getting Buried

When McDavid and Draisaitl leave the ice, the Oilers’ depth forwards have struggled badly.

Not only are they generating very little offense, but they are also getting outplayed defensively. At five-on-five with Edmonton’s two superstars off the ice, the Oilers own a 7-18 goal differential, good for a 28.0 percent goals-for percentage. Their expected goals share sits at just 38.8 percent.

Put simply, Edmonton has scored only seven goals while allowing 18 when McDavid and Draisaitl are on the bench.

That is not a recipe for sustainable success.

As highlighted by Mathewjdp on X, Edmonton ranks near the bottom of the league when it comes to the performance of its depth forwards. Those numbers become even more concerning when you factor in the Oilers’ elevated PDO.

PDO is often referred to as hockey’s “luck” metric, combining a team’s five-on-five shooting percentage and save percentage. League average tends to hover around 100. Through the first 10 games, Edmonton carried a PDO of 105.1, an extremely high number that suggested some regression could be coming. That figure dipped following the loss to Toronto, but it remains a red flag nonetheless.

The Oilers are winning games right now. The concern is whether they can keep doing it this way.

The Case for Separating the Big Two

All signs point to now being the time to split up McDavid and Draisaitl.

Yes, it’s a difficult decision. The duo is producing at a historic pace and putting up video game numbers together. Separating them would undoubtedly weaken one of the most dangerous lines in hockey. But the rest of the lineup is struggling to stay afloat.

The combination of injuries and a lack of center depth has left Edmonton spending far too much time defending whenever their stars aren’t on the ice. Those shifts pile up, players get worn down, and mistakes begin to compound.

Splitting up McDavid and Draisaitl would not magically solve every problem, but it would at least spread elite talent throughout the lineup and give depth players a better opportunity to succeed alongside one of the game’s best playmakers. Right now, keeping them together arguably makes the least sense it has all season.

To be fair, there is a reasonable counterargument. If McDavid and Draisaitl are separated, can either line generate enough offense consistently? It’s a valid question. But with the Oilers’ bottom six getting caved in night after night, Edmonton may not be able to afford waiting much longer to find out.

The Oilers’ hot start has masked a growing problem. If management and the coaching staff ignore the warning signs, that impressive record could disappear far quicker than anyone expects.

Before the damage starts showing up in the standings, Edmonton should seriously consider making the change.

Next: Mike Babcock Has Changed One Key Habit for the Oilers, and It’s Fueling Their Hot Start


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk