The Maple Leafs Let a Good One Slip Away Too Easily?

Bobby McMann is officially staying out west. The Seattle Kraken announced Sunday that they’ve signed the 30-year-old forward to a six-year deal. However, the team did not disclose the terms. For Toronto Maple Leafs fans, it’s easy to see this as one of those “grass is greener” moves. That’s especially true because McMann was a Maple Leafs player who clearly loved playing in Toronto and would have stayed if he had the chance.

---

---

From the Maple Leafs Fans’ Perspective, Seeing McMann Leave Stings

From Toronto’s perspective, this one’s tough. McMann was one of those guys you felt good about having around—he gave effort, bought into the city, and still made an impact even when his role wasn’t always the same. The weird part is the return: traded to Seattle for a 2026 fourth and a conditional 2027 second, which is basically jackpot-level value, so it’s hard not to question what the Leafs leadership had in mind.

It’s not like you’re talking about a random roster body—he had been building momentum, and his season numbers show it. This season, he put up career highs with 29 goals, 17 assists, and 46 points in 78 games. Then, after Toronto traded him to Seattle on March 6, he didn’t just “survive” the change—he produced right away, scoring 10 goals and 14 points overall in 18 games with the Kraken.

The Maple Leafs Didn’t Give McMann the Chance the Kraken Did

This is the kind of result that makes you think Toronto could’ve kept riding that wave. But Seattle gave him more minutes, more trust, and a clearer path to play his game. And that’s where the Maple Leafs perspective gets complicated. If you’re a Maple Leafs fan, you can look at this and feel like, “He loved Toronto. He wanted to stay, and they moved him out for peanuts.”

There’s also the reality that hockey is business, and once a player gets traded and clicks somewhere else, it’s hard not to wonder how different things would’ve been if the opportunity came without the detour. A coaching change could’ve been that fresh start in Toronto, too. But McMann needed the right setup, the right lineup, the right responsibility. He got that in Seattle.

Wishing McMann Well in Seattle

Still, as much as it hurts, many fans can’t help but feel happy for him. McMann’s talent was obvious, and what he did in Seattle looks like the reward for being given real space to operate. He landed in a place that appreciated him, and he proved what he could do when he was in and out of the lineup less and trusted more.

Personally, he’s one of my favourite players on the Maple Leafs, so I’m glad to see him land in a good situation. I’m genuinely happy for where he ended up. When players get more time and responsibility, it can bring out the best in them. McMann earned this, and Seattle clearly sees it.

Related: One New Trade & a Complicated Maple Leafs’ Ripple Effect