The Edmonton Oilers could have an intriguing opportunity to add another Stanley Cup champion to their roster following recent developments surrounding the Pittsburgh Penguins. During Saturday Headlines on October 17, Elliotte Friedman revealed that Pittsburgh is willing to move veteran forwards in exchange for draft picks or prospects as the organization continues transitioning toward a younger roster.
While Bryan Rust and Rickard Rakell appear to be more realistic trade candidates, what if Edmonton explored the possibility of acquiring Evgeni Malkin? The 40-year-old centre remains an effective offensive player and could provide the Oilers with another experienced option down the middle. Although there is no indication Pittsburgh is actively shopping Malkin, here’s a hypothetical trade proposal worth considering.
The Proposed Trade
Edmonton Oilers receive:
- Evgeni Malkin (50% retained, $2.75 million cap hit)
Pittsburgh Penguins receive:
- Josh Samanski
- Quinn Hutson
- 2027 second-round pick
Why the Oilers Would Consider This Deal
For Edmonton, the appeal is straightforward. Malkin would give the Oilers a legitimate second-line centre while allowing Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl to remain together on the top line. Despite his age, Malkin continues to demonstrate his offensive abilities. He recorded 61 points in 56 games last season, proving he can still contribute at a high level when healthy.
A potential top six featuring Vasily Podkolzin, McDavid and Draisaitl on the first line, followed by Zach Hyman, Malkin and Matthew Savoie on the second, would give Edmonton two dangerous scoring units.
Malkin also brings three Stanley Cup championships and a Conn Smythe Trophy, adding valuable postseason experience to a team pursuing its first championship since 1990. At a $2.75 million cap hit, the financial commitment would be manageable compared to acquiring another established top-six forward at full salary, provided Edmonton can create the necessary cap space.
Why Would Pittsburgh Accept?
For Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas, the proposal would align with the organization’s reported willingness to exchange established veterans for younger assets. Samanski and Hutson would provide Pittsburgh with two forwards who could compete for NHL opportunities, while the 2027 second-round pick adds another asset to its rebuilding efforts.
Rather than potentially losing Malkin for nothing if he reaches unrestricted free agency next summer, Pittsburgh could turn an aging veteran into three future assets. However, convincing Malkin to waive his no-movement clause would be the biggest obstacle.
Having spent his entire NHL career with Pittsburgh, leaving would be a significant decision. Nevertheless, the opportunity to chase another Stanley Cup alongside McDavid and Draisaitl could be appealing, particularly if Pittsburgh finds itself outside the playoff picture.
Would Pittsburgh Ask for More?
If Dubas rejected Edmonton’s initial offer, a first-round pick instead of the second could be a potential counteroffer, especially with Pittsburgh retaining half of Malkin’s salary. The Penguins could also request a higher-end prospect if multiple contenders expressed interest. However, Edmonton should be hesitant to surrender a first-round selection for a 40-year-old pending unrestricted free agent.
Waiting until closer to the trade deadline could make more sense, allowing the Oilers to evaluate their biggest roster needs while determining whether Malkin becomes available.
Would you make this trade? Edmonton would acquire a proven playoff performer capable of strengthening its second line, while Pittsburgh would receive three future assets. The question is whether the Oilers should sacrifice two promising forwards and a second-round pick for one potential Stanley Cup run.
Next: Agent Responds to Zadorov Scratch by Bruins with Trade Tease to Maple Leafs
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
More News
