Detroit Red Wings
Oilers Trade Proposal Shows Red Wings’ High Value on DeBrincat
The Edmonton Oilers will likely continue to be linked to scoring wingers as they search for another legitimate top-six option, and one name that makes plenty of sense on paper is Detroit Red Wings forward Alex DeBrincat.
A recent trade proposal had Edmonton acquiring DeBrincat in exchange for Quinn Hutson, Kasperi Kapanen and a protected first-round pick. The proposal generated plenty of discussion, but one thing stood out: Red Wings fans and other observers overwhelmingly believed Detroit would be getting the short end of the deal.
That reaction raises an interesting question about how highly the Red Wings themselves value DeBrincat.
DeBrincat’s Value Might Be Higher Than Expected
There is no question DeBrincat would be an attractive target for Edmonton. He is a proven goal scorer, can play in a top-six role and would give the Oilers another dangerous offensive weapon alongside Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.

However, the reaction to the proposal suggests acquiring him could cost considerably more than Edmonton would be comfortable paying. Hutson is a promising young forward, Kapanen provides an NHL roster piece and a protected first-round pick gives Detroit another significant future asset. From Edmonton’s perspective, that is already a decent package for a rental.
Yet, judging by the response from Detroit fans, it isn’t close.
One response simply read, “No. No. No.” That was hardly an isolated sentiment, as the proposal received significant pushback from those who believe DeBrincat is worth considerably more.
Would Detroit Feel the Same Way?
Fan reaction obviously doesn’t determine a player’s trade value, but it can provide an interesting glimpse into how a player is viewed within a market. DeBrincat isn’t simply regarded as another good top-six winger in Detroit. He’s viewed by many as a core piece. The bigger question is whether Red Wings management shares that valuation.
If Detroit views DeBrincat as an essential part of its long-term plans, Edmonton would likely have to significantly increase its offer just to get a conversation started. That could mean another premium prospect or young NHL player in addition to a first-round pick. At that point, the Oilers should probably look elsewhere.
DeBrincat would undoubtedly improve Edmonton’s top six, but there has to be a limit. If Detroit values him as an untouchable—or close to it—the acquisition cost could quickly outweigh the benefit. The reaction to this proposal may ultimately highlight the biggest obstacle to a DeBrincat trade: the Red Wings might simply value him far more than opposing teams are willing to pay.
Next: 5 Fascinating Facts About ex-Oilers & Maple Leafs Ben Scrivens
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
