Maple Leafs Should Think Twice About Tanking the Season

After the Olympic break, the Toronto Maple Leafs stumbled hard. Loss after loss piled up, and just like that, the season was over before it officially even ended. Fans were upset, the mood around the rink was heavy, and when Auston Matthews went down, it felt like the tank was officially underway.

Logic would say: why not take the losses, grab that fifth-round pick from Boston in the Fraser Minten deal, and start fresh? Makes sense on paper. But here’s the catch — hockey isn’t played on spreadsheets.

---

---

Bo Groulx Became a Catalyst for Rethinking a Maple Leafs Tank Job

Enter Bo Groulx. The youngster’s arrival gave the Maple Leafs a jolt of energy, a spark at exactly the right time. Suddenly, a team that had been trudging through games without life found someone who made them push again.

That’s the kind of thing you can’t quantify in draft picks. When a team gets a bit of momentum, the culture shifts and winning starts to feel contagious. When players start finding space and playing with confidence, because someone like Groulx is flying around, that’s the stuff championships are made of — not just future potential.

Tanking Might Bring Back a Pick, But It Risks More

Tanking might give you a hypothetical payoff in a draft, but it comes with real costs. It teaches habits you don’t want in a professional team. As well, it normalizes disengagement. It tells the young guys that effort is optional, that losing is an acceptable strategy, and that the scoreboard doesn’t really matter.

That’s not how you build a winning culture. Look at how Groulx has energized others. He’s become the exact kind of obstacle a tank needs — because he refuses to check out. He’s fighting for relevance as an NHL player. He wants a job in Toronto. Why wouldn’t he work hard for his future?

The Maple Leafs Are Showing They Have Fight Left

The Maple Leafs still have fight left. A few wins here, some momentum, and the team isn’t just playing out the string — they’re laying a foundation. Bo Groulx didn’t just earn minutes; he earned respect. He made a case for what the team could be if they keep pushing.

You can’t count on replicating what he brought with a draft pick. You can’t trade for culture or energy. Those are built on ice, in the locker room, one shift at a time.

If the “Smart” Logic Is Tanking, That’s Short-Term Thinking

So yes, the math might suggest tanking is “smart.” But in the long run, it’s not. A losing streak might be easy to accept when you’re thinking about a pick, but the habits, morale, and standards it teaches are hard to shake.

The Maple Leafs would be far better off fighting for every point, even in a lost season, than asking their professionals to stop caring. And from where I sit, that’s how you kill a team’s culture.

Related: Host: Parros ‘Clearly Had it Out for the Leafs’ in Biased Gudas Suspension