Could Ryan O’Reilly Return to the Maple Leafs?

Ryan O’Reilly’s brief tenure with the Toronto Maple Leafs left a lasting impact. A couple of seasons ago, he joined the team late in the year. He added valuable experience and helped Toronto secure its first playoff series win in nearly two decades. His leadership, playoff poise, and knack for clutch performances made him an instant fan favorite and a valuable teammate.

He ultimately signed with the Nashville Predators, possibly seeking a lower-pressure environment than the Toronto media spotlight. Still, some Maple Leafs fans can’t help but imagine a scenario where he returns to bolster the team again.

---

---

The Nashville Situation and Rumors of a Rebuild

The Predators are rumored to be considering a “rebuild” as their season trends downward. With a record that suggests they’re unlikely to make the playoffs, the team might be looking to shift direction. This potential rebuild might even open the door for a trade involving veterans like O’Reilly, allowing Nashville to focus on acquiring young talent or draft picks.

While the logistics and fit are speculative at best, O’Reilly’s experience and reputation make him an intriguing asset for any team with playoff aspirations. It raises the question for the Maple Leafs: would bringing him back be a gamble worth taking? The fact is that, in some ways, it would be a no-brainer.

What O’Reilly Could Bring Back to the Maple Leafs

O’Reilly’s time in Toronto showed he brings more than skill on the ice. He provides stability, a calming presence, and deep knowledge of the game. He’s a proven leader and a solid two-way center. As such, his impact on team morale can’t be overstated.

With the Maple Leafs aiming to advance deeper into the playoffs, adding someone with his skill set, even temporarily, could provide the intangible boost often critical in playoff series. A player like O’Reilly could also provide support in key areas where the Maple Leafs have historically needed help, such as faceoffs, defensive reliability, and versatility up front.

Who knows? Perhaps he’ll feel that the Maple Leafs might be a place to hang his hat for longer.

Realistic or Just Wishful Thinking?

While the idea of O’Reilly returning to Toronto feels like wishful thinking, it isn’t entirely out of possibility. There are cap considerations to worry about and O’Reilly is anything but a rental (three seasons remain on his current contract). However, if the Predators decide to go into full rebuild mode and O’Reilly becomes available, the Maple Leafs could consider him to push them through a tough playoff season.

He does not hold trade protection in his contract so nothing is stopping the Preds from making a move, nor the Leafs from flipping O’Reilly again down the road, should they so choose.

Even if it’s a short-term addition, the impact could be significant, both on and off the ice. His familiarity with the team and reputation as a playoff performer could give Toronto the experienced boost they need.

The Bottom Line: Could O’Reilly Be the Missing Piece?

Although this scenario is more fantasy than reality, it’s an intriguing possibility. Adding O’Reilly to the Maple Leafs’ lineup could be the final ingredient for a long-awaited playoff run. His presence would be a reminder of what he brought to Toronto the first time around, and who knows—maybe his second stint would be just what the team needs to get over the playoff hump finally. For now, though, it’s a fun possibility to consider as the season unfolds.

If the Predators fall out of playoff contention, it could be wise for them to consider trading for Ryan O’Reilly to bring him back to the Maple Leafs. Not only would this provide Nashville with future assets, but it would also allow O’Reilly to rejoin a Stanley Cup-contending team.

Related: Maple Leafs Activate Jani Hakanpaa From LTIR, Ready To Play?