Bednar Comments Put Makar In Awkward Spot Ahead of Game 3

Colorado Avalanche coach Jared Bednar’s recent comments regarding Cale Makar’s injury have created an uncomfortable spotlight on the star defenseman just ahead of a pivotal Game 3. To many, there’s a difference between telling the truth and making sure that when you tell it, you do so in a way that supports your superstar. Bednar arguably didn’t do that after the Game 2 loss.

---

When asked about the Norris Trophy winner’s status, Bednar responded: “It’s gonna be Cale’s decision on if he’s coming back. He’s doing all the work. I don’t make that decision for him.”

The remark was intended to be straightforward, but it has drawn significant criticism from fans who feel it puts unnecessary pressure on Makar and indirectly questions his drive and compete level. With the Avalanche now down 2-0 in their series with the Vegas Golden Knights, it was already clear Makar was a big part of the Avs’ game plan. They miss him and they need him to get back into this series.

It’s not clear if he’ll be ready for Game 3, but the comments put the ball completely in Makar’s court. Fans will now question why he isn’t in, since he “could” be able to go. Or, if he is, will he be coming back too soon?

Social media erupted quickly after the comment. Many Avalanche supporters viewed it as Bednar shifting responsibility onto his best player rather than shielding him during a critical playoff moment.

What Bednar Probably Should Have Said About Makar

‘That’ll be a decision that Cale and our medical staff make. When he’s ready, he’s ready’ is all he needed to say,” one fan posted, while another wrote, “Talk about throwing him under the bus.” Several compared Bednar unfavorably to other coaches, with one noting, “I bet Dan Muse would never make a comment like that.” Josh Yohe of The Athletic wrote, “Were I Cale Makar, I don’t think I’d appreciate this comment.” When a fan questioned why it was a big deal to tell the truth, which is essentially what Bedar did, Yohe responded with, “I didn’t say it wasn’t true. In my experience with HOF players, they don’t particularly like when they aren’t supported publicly by their head coach.”

Additional reactions highlighted the timing and stakes. “This feels like the type of comment that you don’t come back from if the team doesn’t come back in the series,” one user said. Others pointed out that Makar is slated to become an unrestricted free agent after next season, making any perceived slight particularly risky.

Not everyone disagreed with Bednar. A portion of fans defended the coach, arguing the statement was honest and that only Makar truly knows his body. “There’s a difference between hurt and injured,” one observer noted. Some questioned Makar’s willingness to play through something… which, to be honest, might not have been a question if Bedar hadn’t said what he said.

As the Avalanche prepare for Game 3, the focus remains squarely on whether Makar can play — and how Bednar’s public comments may affect team dynamics.

Next: Marner’s Revival in Vegas Shows the Power of Role Over Reputation