Connect with us

Toronto Maple Leafs

This Surprising Maple Leafs Statistic Tells a Sad Story

Auston Matthews leads the Maple Leafs in dangerous-chance numbers, but William Nylander’s position at the bottom raises questions.

The central question: Are the Toronto Maple Leafs getting enough dangerous-chance contributions from their forwards beyond Auston Matthews?

A new chart was released today that looks at how the Toronto Maple Leafs forwards are performing in expected mid- and high-danger chances for and against at even strength. There’s no surprise that Auston Matthews is at the top of the chart. But there is a huge surprise: William Nylander is at the bottom of the chart.

Matthews’ number is +5.12, while Nylander’s is -3.42. That’s a huge difference between two really important Maple Leafs forwards.

What Do These Numbers Really Tell Us About the Maple Leafs?

The chart looks at expected plus/minus. In other words, it compares the dangerous chances a player is expected to create with those he is expected to allow. A positive number shows a favourable balance, and a negative number shows an unfavourable balance.

Let’s look at what Matthews is doing first. He’s leading the way with the best number on the chart at plus 5.12. As I mentioned before, his even-strength minutes are associated with more high-danger chances for Toronto than against. And that’s what the numbers suggest. He’s having an impact in this measure, which is encouraging for the Maple Leafs.

The question now is whether the other forwards are producing similar results, and the answer is no. What’s most interesting is Nylander’s numbers. These negative numbers raise an important question. His -3.42 contrasts sharply with Matthews. What makes it even more problematic for the Maple Leafs is that Nylander is an important offensive player, so his numbers deserve a close look.

As a caveat, we shouldn’t use one statistic to suggest that he’s playing poorly or well. The chart doesn’t capture everything he brings to the ice, and we need more information before we draw any conclusions about his value.

What About the Rest of the Forward Group?

There are a number of other forwards on the chart, and I’ll introduce them right now. Here are the positive numbers.

Other forwards with positive numbers:

  • Kirill Marchenko: +2.71
  • Zack MacEwen: +2.61
  • Jack Roslovic: +2.57
  • Easton Cowan: +1.86
  • Dakota Joshua: +1.54
  • Ryan Tverberg: +0.61

It’s important that the Maple Leafs get contributions across all their lines, and Matthews isn’t the only forward with a favourable expected-chance balance. Cowan’s positive number is worth a closer look, especially because the Maple Leafs have lost so many games in a row.

But there are also a number of forwards with more difficult numbers, and I’ll list those as well.

  • Benoit-Olivier Groulx: -0.13
  • Vinni Lettieri: -1.52
  • John Tavares: -1.54
  • Brandon Duhaime: -1.78
  • Colton Sissons: -1.97
  • Gavin McKenna: -2.18
  • Theodore Blueger: -2.71
  • Nick Paul: -2.84
  • William Nylander: -3.42

The figures suggest that the results aren’t positive across the entire forward group. Again, they are starting points for talking about what’s going on, but not final judgments on the individual players.

Auston Matthews Maple Leafs return
Auston Matthews Maple Leafs

So What Should We Make of These Numbers as Maple Leafs Fans?

Clearly, Nylander’s position stands out because of its negative value. Matthews’ position stands out for its positive value. But several other forwards show encouraging numbers.

And the big question is whether Toronto can get more consistent dangerous-chance contributions across its forward lines. One chart can’t answer all the team’s questions, but it does offer some insight into where the forward group stands. There are more minus numbers than positive numbers.

Now the next step is to see what happens as the season unfolds. Will these numbers change? One can hope they improve for Nylander, but who knows? That’s the question.

Related: Maple Leafs GM Defends Bold Roster Moves, Hints at More Trades


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk