Connect with us

Edmonton Oilers

Oilers’ Top 6 Trade Chips Revealed: Who Bowman Could Move in a Pinch

The Athletic’s Allan Mitchell ranks the Oilers’ top six trade chips. See who Bowman could move if things get tight.


In a column for The Athletic, Allan Mitchell argues that Edmonton Oilers GM Stan Bowman will have to trade prospects to improve the roster, and that left-handed defencemen are his best chips.

As often happens when the Oilers suffer a big loss — as they did Saturday night to the Toronto Maple Leafs — it feels like the sky is falling. Edmonton is 8-2-1, so they’re far from in trouble, but Saturday’s marquee matchup showed signs that the Oilers lacked the depth to compete against a hungrier, more motivated Maple Leafs roster.

No one should be surprised that trade articles are popping up less than 24 hours later.

Mitchell notes the Oilers have had success promoting minor leaguers in recent years, including Philip Broberg, Dylan Holloway, Stuart Skinner and Matt Savoie. Bowman has a 2027 second-round pick and four selections in rounds 5 to 7, so prospects will have to carry the load. Most of those playing professionally aren’t generating much trade interest yet.

Who Might the Oilers Be Able to Trade?

Mitchell ranks his six top trade assets:

Isaac (Ike) Howard:

The 22-year-old winger is the top piece, but he’s playing just 8:10 a night at five-on-five under coach Mike Babcock. He was a healthy scratch on Saturday versus Toronto. His value would rise with a bigger role or power-play time. It’s unclear whether he’ll get that this season. Babcock said he owed Howard more ice time in a game that didn’t let him get the young man on as much as he’d like. The follow-up to those comments with a visit to the press box was interesting.

Damien Carfagna:

Bakersfield’s top defenceman, with five points in six games. Mitchell calls him expendable given Edmonton’s left-side depth. The only issue here is that the depth might be misleading. Even in the game on Saturday when Jake Walman was tripped and needed help off the ice, the immediate thought was who might be called up with another injury. Walman did return and was no worse for wear, but a play like that makes you think.

Tomas Cibulka:

A 22-year-old defenceman with strong mobility who impressed in preseason and in the AHL. Mitchell writes, “He’s a left-handed defenceman like Carfagna, and offers Oilers management an opportunity to trade from strength. A rival team asking for either would receive an undersized defender with a range of skills and impressive mobility who is NHL-ready or close.”

Asher Barnett:

A 2025 fifth-round pick starring at Michigan, possibly the system’s best defenceman. The Oilers may prefer to keep him, though his rugged style could attract offers.

Josh Samanski:

A center who lost the fourth-line job to Owen Michaels and Colton Dach. He has penalty-killing value but wouldn’t fetch a major return. There were high hopes for Samanski coming into this season. He’s not wowed the new coaching staff, which is a bit of a disappointment.

Josh Samanski called up Oilers
Josh Samanski called up Oilers

Zack Sharp:

A 21-year-old Western Michigan defender acquired in the Darnell Nurse trade, with shutdown potential.

Mitchell concludes that Bowman should shop a left-handed defenceman, and that Mattias Ekholm, Jake Walman, Ryan Shea and Shakir Mukhamadullin already fill the NHL spots there. He expects a middle-six forward in return, with Ryan O’Reilly and Dmitri Voronkov mentioned as possible targets. He also floats packaging Howard with a defenceman and the 2027 second-rounder for the right fit.

Next: Composed, But “Wound Up” Babcock Embarrassed by Oilers’ 7-2 Loss to Former Team


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk