NHL Trade Talk Recap: Maple Leafs, Canucks & Oilers Big Trade?

This edition (May 9, 2026) of NHL Trade Talk Recap includes three quick hits from today: It’s wild to think the Maple Leafs might actually flip the No. 1 pick. McKenna’s elite but Toronto’s depth and aging defence could make multiple picks more tempting. The Canucks losing out on No. 3 still isn’t doom since a deep draft and weird fits by Toronto/San Jose could hand McKenna to the Canucks anyway.

And San Jose moving up to No. 2 has people dreaming big trades. Could the Oilers move Darnell Nurse? Or his $9.25M cap hit, no-move clause, and Edmonton needing way more than just him, make that one pretty unrealistic?

Could the Maple Leafs Actually Trade the No. 1 Pick?

Weird thought: it feels sacrilegious to even imagine the Maple Leafs flipping a potential No. 1 pick, but history has weirder takes. The Eric Lindros trade changed a franchise, so nothing’s totally impossible. The math’s the hook: Gavin McKenna might be a generational guy, but Toronto’s real problems are depth, defence, and balance. One superstar won’t fix a thin pipeline and aging D, so maybe multiple first-round assets that fill several holes could be worth more than one shiny name.

Still, pulling the trigger would be brutal. Lots of teams (St. Louis, San Jose, Vancouver, etc.) could cobble together tempting packages, but Toronto’s prospect cupboard is light, and the Maple Leafs might need immediate help, not just future lottery tickets. It’s plausible on paper, messy in real life, and only worth doing if the return actually fixes several problems at once.

Would the Maple Leafs Trade Away Their First Overall?

Could McKenna Still Fall Into the Canucks’ Lap?

Losing out in the lottery stings, but picking third isn’t doom. This draft’s deep, and Vancouver could still land a game-changer. If Toronto and San Jose value fit and balance over flash, there’s a legit scenario where Gavin McKenna slides to No. 3, and the Canucks get the electric winger everyone’s drooling over.

The theory’s simple: Toronto might pick a heavier, more complete RW to pair with Matthews, and San Jose could grab a top-end right-shot defenseman instead of another forward. If both do that, Vancouver gets to act like they never dropped a spot. He’d be a hometown superstar. Landing at No. 3 would turn a rough lottery night into a huge win.

Insider Suggests Canucks Could Still Land Gavin McKenna After Lottery Slide

Darnell Nurse for No. 2? Wild Trade Talk for the Sharks

Mark Lazerus floated the idea that San Jose, sitting at No. 2 and needing D, might try to trade the pick for an established piece — and he even name-dropped Darnell Nurse as a possibility. Yeah, that got people fired up, mostly because Nurse’s $9.25M cap hit and no-move clause make him a massive, complicated asset to move. It’s not exactly a clean swap for a top-two pick.

Fans roasted the idea in the comments, and it makes sense: Edmonton would need more than just Nurse in any real deal, and Nurse would have to agree to waive his clause. So while the headline is juicy, the reality is messy. Still, it’s fun to imagine, but unlikely unless a much bigger package is involved and Nurse is on board.

Scribe Floats Trade That Could Land Oilers No. 2 Pick

More Stories:

Canadian Daily Rumours: Maple Leafs, Flames & Oilers’ Woman Coach
The NHL Playoffs Have Been Dominated by These Two Powerhouses
Trade Pitch Would Form Jack Hughes-Auston Matthews Duo in New Jersey
Current Maple Leaf Lobbying for Swedish Prospect Over Gavin McKenna?
Mitch Marner’s Hat Trick, and Crushing Old Maple Leafs Playoff Numbers