Connect with us

Edmonton Oilers

How the Tristan Jarry Trade Went From Disaster to Major Win for the Oilers

Tristan Jarry’s disastrous start in Edmonton is a distant memory. With Jarry thriving and the Oilers’ goaltending surging, the trade is a win


The Edmonton Oilers and Tristan Jarry got off to a rough start after the trade.

Jarry looked solid in his first few appearances after arriving in Edmonton, but an injury quickly derailed his momentum. Before the trade, he had been playing some excellent hockey, posting a 2.66 GAA and .909 save percentage. Once he returned from injury, however, he never looked quite the same.

By the end of the season, Jarry had appeared in just 19 games for the Oilers, posting a dreadful 3.86 GAA and .858 save percentage. With two years remaining on his $5.375 million cap hit, the trade quickly began to look like a major mistake.

Now? The narrative surrounding the deal may be changing in a big way.

The Trade Looked Like a Disaster

Initially, it was difficult to find any scenario where Edmonton came out ahead.

Stuart Skinner remained the same inconsistent goaltender Oilers fans knew all too well. After arriving in Pittsburgh, he got off to a strong start before eventually falling back toward his career averages. He later signed a two-year deal with the Winnipeg Jets carrying a modest $3.75 million AAV.

Brett Kulak was also a popular player in Edmonton, but moving him did help create much-needed cap flexibility. At the time of the trade, however, the Oilers were selling low. His underlying numbers had declined significantly and ranked among the worst on the team.

The biggest head-scratcher was the inclusion of a second-round pick. Considering Edmonton was taking on Jarry’s contract, many questioned why additional assets were needed to complete the deal.

With Jarry struggling so badly after arriving in Edmonton, there was little reason to believe the Oilers had won the trade. Skinner was still viewed as a serviceable starter, while Kulak eventually netted Pittsburgh Samuel Girard and another second-round pick in a deadline deal with Colorado, making Edmonton’s return look even lighter by comparison.

Tristan Jarry Oilers scrum
Tristan Jarry Oilers

Are the Oilers Actually Winning This Trade?

Fast forward to this season, and the picture looks dramatically different.

Kulak struggled after joining Colorado and never found his footing. His playoff performance was especially disappointing given his reputation for elevating his game in the postseason. Despite that, he landed a five-year contract worth $4.5 million annually.

Meanwhile, Edmonton replaced much of Kulak’s value by signing Ryan Shea to a five-year contract worth $4 million per season. Shea has not only provided strong results, but he’s doing so while being three years younger.

Kulak’s struggles have continued this year, while Skinner’s inconsistency has followed him to Winnipeg. Through this point in the season, Skinner owns the worst numbers of his NHL career, posting a 3.38 GAA, .880 save percentage, and a troubling -1.5 goals saved above expecteed (GSAx), which is 49th in the league.

Then there’s Jarry.

After a difficult season opener, Jarry has been outstanding for Edmonton. Through 10 games, he owns a 2.45 GAA and .912 save percentage, ranking among the league’s better goaltenders. He already has two shutouts and a +3.6 GSAx, representing nearly a five-goal swing compared to Skinner.

If you remove Jarry’s first appearance and look at Edmonton’s last 20 games, his GSAx jumps to +6.0, placing him among the NHL’s top goaltenders over that span.

Jarry Has Completely Changed the Narrative

For years, Edmonton’s goaltending situation was viewed as one of the organization’s biggest weaknesses. Now, it may be one of its strengths.

Jarry looks like a completely different goaltender than the one Oilers fans saw immediately following the trade. His confidence has returned, he’s making difficult saves consistently, and he’s giving Edmonton a chance to win nearly every time he starts.

When combined with Skinner’s struggles in Winnipeg and Kulak’s decline in Colorado, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to call this anything other than a win for Edmonton.

No one knows what the 2029 second-round pick will eventually become, but if Jarry continues performing at this level, the Oilers likely won’t care. They’re getting significantly better goaltending while spending less money than they would have on Skinner and Kulak combined.

The deal already looked like it was beginning to tilt in Edmonton’s favor. Now, there’s a legitimate argument that it is becoming a major win.

Considering how disastrous it looked just one season ago, that’s a remarkable turnaround.

Next: Connor McDavid Is on Pace for Something Hockey Hasn’t Seen Since Wayne Gretzky


Discover more from NHL Trade Talk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

More News

PuckPedia NHL Trade Talk