Reactionary Coaching Move Could Cost Maple Leafs a Good GM

The Toronto Maple Leafs may be watching the NHL coaching market thin out, but that doesn’t mean they should rush into a decision.

That was the topic of discussion between Nick Kypreos and Justin Bourne, who debated how quickly Toronto needs to act as names start coming off the board. With the New York Islanders quickly locking up Pete DeBoer and the Vegas Golden Knights making a sudden change from Bruce Cassidy to John Tortorella, do the Maple Leafs need to get out there quickly and snag a coach like Cassidy while he’s available?

---

Kypreos pushed back on the idea that the Leafs should feel urgency just to keep pace with teams like the Islanders or Golden Knights. Bourne suggested they don’t have much choice, given that the team hasn’t hired a new general manager yet.

The Maple Leafs Need a GM First

Without a GM or president of hockey operations in place, making any coaching hire premature. That means losing out on a top coach might be something the organization has to live with, assuming the names available are on their list of top bench bosses. The Maple Leafs can’t put the cart before the horse. The risk is a disconnect in vision or hiring someone the new GM doesn’t agree with, potentially leading a top GM candidate to remove themselves from consideration.

While Bourne acknowledged the concern that top candidates are disappearing, he also suggested the Islanders acted decisively because their front offices were already stable. Toronto is anything but.

What the team doesn’t need is to chase someone like Cassidy, or Patrick Roy, only to find out that neither was on the radar of the best managers, most of whom will want to hire their own coach.

The Maple Leafs Can’t Afford to Be Reactionary

There’s also the risk of making a reactionary move, which rarely serves anyone in the long term. Just because Vegas made a switch, and it seems to be working under John Tortorella, doesn’t mean the Maple Leafs should see that as the template for their team. Yes, the Vegas Golden Knights created a domino effect across the league, and Cassidy might be the guy the Leafs want, but reacting to outside pressure is exactly what the Leafs should avoid.

Waiting allows Toronto to properly assess its options, align its front office, and identify the right fit—rather than simply the most recognizable name left on the market.

Next: Maple Leafs Need Two Hires to Solve Their Failure Modes