Strip Away All the New Nylander Noise, What is the Maple Leafs Forward, Really?

I’ve learned over the years that if you really want to understand a hockey player in Toronto, you don’t start with the highlight reels or the contract numbers. You listen to the fans. That’s where this conversation about William Nylander came from. In a recent post I wrote comparing Nylander’s on-ice play with Auston Matthews’, fans told me what they think of him.

---

I admit I read the fans’ comments closely, but I don’t always agree with them. In this case, I don’t agree. But that doesn’t mean I’ll ignore what the fans have to say. In fact, here it is.

Nylander has been here long enough that fans aren’t asking what he might become. They’re asking what he is. And the answers, while blunt, are surprisingly consistent.

The Fans Believe Nylander Is a One-Way Player

For many fans, the case against Nylander is simple and long settled. They see a player who plays in one direction and only one. The skill is obvious — no one disputes that. But defence, physical engagement, and attention away from the puck are viewed as choices he’s never fully made. This isn’t framed as a lack of talent. Quite the opposite. Fans argue that defensive play doesn’t require brilliance, just effort and awareness. In that light, Nylander’s habits aren’t misunderstood — they’re intentional.

That’s why references to both Sheldon Keefe and Craig Berube come up. Different coaches, same friction. To these fans, that’s not a coincidence. It’s a pattern.

The Fans Believe Nylander Has Thick Skin or Closed Ears

Another strain of commentary focuses less on shifts and more on personality. Nylander, fans say, has an uncommon ability to block out Toronto noise. He doesn’t ride the emotional waves that swallow other players. That’s often praised; until it isn’t. Fans are concerned that the same mental armour that protects him from the market also shields him from critique.

When the team loses, or a coach is visibly frustrated, there’s a belief that Nylander isn’t especially rattled. For some, that’s professionalism. For others, it reads as detachment. The question fans keep circling is whether he’s calm under pressure — or simply unmoved by it.

Some Maple Leafs Fans Believe Nylander Is a Star Cast in the Wrong Role

Not all the criticism lands squarely at Nylander’s feet. Some fans widen the lens and argue he was never meant to be a cornerstone, let alone a conscience for the team. In that view, Nylander would have thrived elsewhere, especially on a strong defensive roster that wanted him to score, create, and stay out of the way otherwise. Plenty of Stanley Cup teams would have room for that kind of player.

Toronto, however, asked for more. Leadership by example. Commitment in all three zones. Emotional investment. Fans questioning this path aren’t excusing Nylander so much as suggesting he’s been miscast from the start.

Less Money, Fewer Moments, and More Shrugs

One of the more thoughtful takes touched on status and timing. Nylander was the most naturally gifted of the core, some argue, yet spent years as the third name in every headline. Lower paid, less defended, and quietly expected to adjust. Over time, that may have shaped a simple philosophy: play the game your way, take the paycheque, and let others carry the emotional weight.

It’s not framed as greed. It’s framed as acceptance—a player who decided long ago that fighting the current in Toronto wasn’t worth the energy.

So, Who Do Fans Think Nylander Is?

If you strip away the frustration, the admiration, and the what-ifs, fans seem to agree on one thing: William Nylander is exactly who he’s always been. Brilliant with the puck. Selective without it. Mentally insulated. Unbothered by the storms around him.

The unresolved question isn’t whether he can change. It’s whether this version of Nylander fits what Toronto still wants to be. After all these years, that may say as much about the Maple Leafs as it does about the player wearing the number.

Nylander has been moved up to the top line again for the Maple Leafs as Berube tries to find chemistry that will get that top unit going. Berube feels moving Nylander to the top line with Auston Matthews could be “really good,” and it’s not just about one guy.

Related: Maple Leafs Trade for Dougie Hamilton? Who’s Kidding Who?