Oilers Shake Rumor of “Deep Routed Roster Issue” With Effort vs Lightning

If there were any lingering questions about whether something was “deeply wrong” inside the Edmonton Oilers’ dressing room, Thursday’s 2–1 overtime loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning was a direct rebuttal. The defeat dropped Edmonton to 9-9-5, but the game itself looked nothing like a team fractured, unmotivated, or quietly at war with its coach.

---

That’s notable because earlier in the day, TSN’s Jeff O’Neill suggested the Oilers’ inconsistent, disorganized play looked like the symptom of a behind-the-scenes problem. “They have some serious problems, serious, serious problems,” O’Neill said, adding that the lack of energy and engagement resembled a group dealing with internal friction. “It looks like there’s potentially some type of issue… somebody’s pissed at somebody… some kind of deep-rooted issue that’s showing its ugly head on the ice.”

If that theory had any legs, Edmonton’s response in Tampa stomped on it.

Traveling on no rest, arriving at 2:30 a.m., and playing the second half of a back-to-back, the Oilers came out with one of their most energized starts of the season. Trent Frederic’s early goal was a big lift for the group. Darnell Nurse‘s fight with Curtis Douglas was one teammate standing up for another. Calvin Pickard played well, and the group in front of him played exceptionally better than they had been—three things that likely wouldn’t have happened if the locker room was fractured.

This was a team that appeared as though they’d had enough of playing like hot garbage. When everything was stacked against them in terms of timing, travel, and motivation, they found the kind of energy they’ve been missing most of the season.

An Oilers Team That Has Issue Doesn’t Show This Kind of Energy

The team’s structure was tight, the compete level was high, and Pickard delivered his best game of the year with a 33-save performance. The defense in front of him—Evan Bouchard, Mattias Ekholm, and Darnell Nurse—played cohesively. Jake Walman took a physical beating, getting crunched on a hit and then blocking a shot. The forwards didn’t score more than one goal, but they pushed and were moving, forechecking hard and winning puck battles, something that had been missing for weeks.

The loss still stings, especially after Jack Roslovic nearly ended it seconds before Jake Guentzel scored the winner. But the effort, the commitment, and the connectedness on display say far more about the Oilers’ trajectory than the final score. If there was ever a night to disprove the idea of a fractured team, this was it.

The real test will be Saturday’s game versus the Florida Panthers. There’s no game the Oilers need more to get up for than this one. If Edmonton can’t motivate themselves to get a win against the team that eliminated them twice in the Stanley Cup Final in back-to-back seasons, what are we doing here?

Next: Red-Hot Jesper Wallstedt Has Oilers Fans Revisiting Controversial Draft Decision