Beyond Roster Trade, Maple Leafs Have Hit a Breaking Point

The Toronto Maple Leafs are officially in crisis mode. Seven losses in eight games, a 1-5-2 spiral, and a level of disjointed, uninspired hockey this team simply hasn’t shown in years. Every season, the roster changes. Every season, the coach has the same message and frustration with the way the team plays. Every year, the excuses change.

---

Recent reports suggest the Maple Leafs are looking at making a roster-for-roster trade, but it’s hard to imagine that will accomplish much. With the top stars remaining and a team that is getting older, finding their way back is going to be a challenge. At some point, you stop looking at management or the bench and start noticing the only constant: nothing ever actually changes where it matters.

Saturday’s 5–2 loss in Montreal was just the latest chapter in a season that’s veering completely off the rails. Toronto has lost all but one of its seven road games and is second-last in the Eastern Conference of the NHL. The team is missing several key pieces, which means Injuries aren’t helping. It only got worse on Saturday as Jake McCabe took a puck to the face and could miss time. Still, the Maple Leafs were already playing poorly before bodies started dropping. So too, Montreal was missing four key players and still dictated the game from start to finish.

Related: Svechnikov Open to Trade, Teams Calling Hurricanes Need Monster Offer

By the time the Canadiens doubled their lead, they had outshot Toronto 16–1 to start the second period and chased Joseph Woll from the net. Head coach Craig Berube didn’t mince words afterward. He didn’t blame Woll, saying the Leafs were giving up freebies. He added he’d had enough and noted, “This is a veteran hockey team. It’s inexcusable,” he said. “Until we play for 60 minutes, it’s going to be hard to pull yourself out of anything.”

A Quick Trade Isn’t Going to Fix the Maple Leafs’ Problems

Toronto dominated early, he said, but once Montreal scored, the Leafs folded instead of pushing back. John Tavares admitted the second period “put us in a big hole” and acknowledged the weight of a season that already feels heavy.

The truth is, Toronto should be far more competitive than this. They’re old, slow, soft, and stale—a far cry from the energetic up-and-coming teams that are about to take over the NHL. Management stuck too long with a core and then went on to add pieces that don’t make them faster, especially defensively. This is a team beyond one roster-for-roster trade fixing anything.

The Leafs need to change their mentality, find a different gear, or go in a new direction if they want to save this season. Does that mean a coaching change? It would let the players off the hook and maybe the team waits until it gets a few players back from injury, but don’t rule it out.

Next: Maple Leafs Depth Destroyed? A Shocking Number of Picks Given Up