New Jersey Devils
Host Calls for Far-Fetched Trade Between Maple Leafs and Devils
One host suggested a far-fetched trade between the Toronto Maple Leafs and New Jersey Devils, a one-for-one deal involving two defensemen.
It’s hard to imagine a world in which this is a trade that actually goes down, but Adam Wylde of the SDPN show is suggesting (perhaps sarcastically) that the New Jersey Devils accept a trade that would see them deal Dougie Hamilton to the Toronto Maple Leafs for Simon Benoit.
At first glance, the trade feels absurd. One is a former Norris Trophy finalist with a $9 million cap hit; the other is a physical, low-offense depth defenseman with a $1.35 million hit. That said, there is a path — albeit a narrow one — where both teams might entertain the conversation. At the very least, some iteration of it.
From Toronto’s perspective, the appeal is obvious. With Chris Tanev likely done for the season, the Maple Leafs are thin on the right side. They would like an upgrade in the position. Hamilton, even in a down year, offers elite puck-moving ability, power-play upside, and playoff experience. It’s a hefty price tag, but if the Devils were willing to retain a little on his salary, it becomes an attractive idea. That’s a big ask from the Devils, considering the time left in Hamilton’s contract.
If the Devils won’t retain salary and the Leafs can creatively manage the cap through LTIR or other means, moving a depth player like Benoit to acquire Hamilton represents a rare swing that could pay off handsomely.
Why Would the Devils Entertain This Trade Idea?
For New Jersey, this isn’t so much about acquiring Benoit as it is more about roster flexibility and clearing out a big contract. The Devils are rumored to be willing to part with Hamilton’s contract if it allows them to do other things. Moving him would open significant cap space, and the organization could reshape its defense around younger, more mobile pieces. The timing of a deal with Luke Hughes, who has recently been injured, doesn’t look convenient right now, but much of that will depend on how long Hughes is out.
Benoit, while not a centerpiece, could serve as an inexpensive stopgap depth defender while New Jersey prioritizes futures — picks or prospects — as part of a larger deal framework.
One-for-One Seems Unlikely
In reality, Benoit would almost certainly be just one component of a more complex trade. Because of the salary cap implications and the value difference between the two players, there would be more involved. How much more is up for debate.
Still, with Hamilton’s name gaining traction on trade boards and Toronto actively searching for defensive help, it’s not surprising to see speculative ideas surface.
Far-fetched? Absolutely. Impossible? Not entirely — and that’s why the conversation won’t go away.
Next: Maple Leafs, Canadiens Among Teams in Pursuit of Flames Star
More News
