Canucks Can’t Make Marner Mistake: Hughes Trade Down to 4 Possible Outcomes

The Quinn Hughes situation in Vancouver has turned into the biggest story of the past several weeks, with analysts and insiders getting close to predicting that a trade is close to happening. Canucks President Jim Rutherford and GM Patrik Allvin know this is the most significant trade they will makell make for this organization and that whatever happens next will follow them for decades.

---

The fallout from the JT Miller trade that saw the team gamble and fail on Filip Chytil still lingers. Fans are worried, well aware that an experienced front office missed on a risk that was obvious to everyone else. They can’t repeat the same mistake with Hughes, who, if traded for the wrong return, will leave the Canucks feeling like the Toronto Maple Leafs after they moved Mitch Marner.

Toronto had plenty of chances to get it right, and that Marner trade appears likely to haunt them for some time. Getting Nicholas Roy and trying to replace Marner with a handful of wingers that haven’t moved the needle has stung. The adverse domino effect it has had on the roster, including Auston Matthews, is real.

The Hughes Trade Isn’t Just Any Trade for the Canucks

This isn’t just any trade discussion. This is a franchise-altering decision involving one of the two best defensemen on the planet.

Speculation surged after ESPN’s Greg Wyshynski highlighted Hughes’ desire to eventually play with brothers Jack and Luke in New Jersey. Hughes didn’t help cool things off, casually referring to Devils GM Tom Fitzgerald as “Fitzy.” Sure, that could be chalked up to Team USA familiarity ahead of the 2026 Olympics — but the Vancouver market isn’t in the mood for casual.

According to Wyshynski, the Hughes saga appears headed down one of four paths:

1. The fairytale extension. Hughes recommits to Vancouver long-term. Nobody’s betting on this.

2. The New Jersey prophecy. The Canucks trade Hughes to the Devils, likely involving top prospect Simon Nemec. Some believe Vancouver actually covets Nico Hischier, but it’s hard to imagine the Devils gutting themselves that deeply.

3. The lame-duck years. Hughes plays out the next two seasons before bolting in 2027. Vancouver would be roasted alive for letting that happen.

4. The maximize-now option. The Canucks move him with term on his deal and target young centers who can help immediately. Detroit has quickly become the most popular candidate, with names like Marco Kasper, Nate Danielson, and Simon Edvinsson floated. Philadelphia, the Rangers, Anaheim, Carolina, Dallas, and even Washington have also surfaced as logical suitors.

Around the league, the belief remains the same: Quinn Hughes will eventually play with his brothers. The only questions are when — and which team ultimately makes the Canucks an offer they can’t refuse.

Next: Could Celebrini Be a Better Player Than McDavid?