As the Edmonton Oilers continue to explore ways to solidify their middle-six ahead of the stretch run, one name gaining traction among NHL insiders is Toronto Maple Leafs forward Bobby McMann. Both Elliotte Friedman and Bob Stauffer have publicly pointed to McMann as a player who could fit seamlessly into Edmonton’s lineup, and the logic behind that belief is easy to understand.
McMann may not carry star power, but his blend of size, skating, and north-south play checks several boxes for an Oilers team that has leaned heavily on its top stars in recent seasons.
Why McMann Fits Edmonton’s Needs
At 6-foot-2 and over 217 pounds, McMann brings a physical element that the Oilers’ forward group often lacks outside of their top six. He plays a direct game, gets in on the forecheck, and is comfortable driving the net — traits that tend to translate well in playoff hockey.
What is perhaps most interesting about McMann is that he has the ability to keep up with skilled players. McMann is a good skater for his size and has demonstrated glimpses of scoring potential when used in an offensive capacity with the Toronto organization. McMann is not likely to be asked to be a goal-scorer, but the underlying statistics do indicate that he has the ability to create scoring chances when used correctly.
As it relates to the Edmonton organization, McMann has the potential to be used on the third line and potentially jump up into the lineup at times.
Stauffer and Friedman See the Same Picture
Bob Stauffer has continually stressed the need to acquire players who can complement the skills of the team’s stars rather than duplicate the skills of the players. McMann is the perfect candidate for such a role. He does not require any power-play time, wins battles in the boards, and can create space for more skilled players.
Elliotte Friedman also expressed similar views, stating that McMann’s characteristics, such as being affordable, controllable, and versatile, are often the target of contenders in the lead-up to the deadline. For a team that is already tight on the salary cap, these factors are just as important as the on-ice performance.
A Logical Trade Framework: Mangiapane for McMann
If Edmonton were to pursue McMann, a realistic trade framework could involve Andrew Mangiapane, a draft pick, and a prospect heading to Toronto.
Proposed Trade:
- Oilers receive: Bobby McMann
- Maple Leafs receive: Andrew Mangiapane + 2026 second-round pick + Roby Järventie
From Edmonton’s perspective, this deal impacts their middle six. Mangiapane has been an effective player, but his offense has been inconsistent. His salary is also higher than McMann’s. This deal allows Edmonton financial flexibility and gets them a player that fits their current team identity better.
From Toronto’s perspective, Mangiapane is an attractive addition. He has proven goal-scoring ability and has played in the playoffs. He can play both wings, and this deal gives him a fresh start. The draft pick and a prospect also motivate Toronto to make this deal.
Why This Deal Makes Sense for Both Teams
Toronto is in perpetual search of secondary scoring that can produce in high-leverage situations. Mangiapane has proven he can produce at the NHL level and could use the opportunity to play in a new system with different expectations.
As for Edmonton, they would be taking a chance on fit rather than flair. McMann’s deal and role fit better with what they need as they try to manage the playing time for Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, as well as build a roster that can win in the postseason.
Final Thoughts
Bobby McMann may not be making headlines, but that is often the case with players who end up becoming key contributors for Cup contenders. With respected voices such as Bob Stauffer and Elliotte Friedman calling him a good fit, it would not be surprising if Edmonton pursued this option.
If Edmonton is looking for ways to balance their lineup and add depth without giving up future cap space, McMann is the type of move that may quietly pay dividends when it matters most.
Next: TSN Scout: Team Canada Should Swap “Safe” Defenseman for Evan Bouchard
More News
